Questo articolo esamina le differenze tra la maternità surrogata e la fecondazione assistita per quanto riguarda i costi, il tasso di successo, le considerazioni legali, i vantaggi e gli svantaggi. Approfondisce i vantaggi e gli svantaggi della Maternità surrogata e della FIV dal punto di vista dei genitori intenzionali e delle madri surrogate. Offriamo una visione esaustiva per determinare se la Maternità surrogata o la FIVET sono l'approccio più adatto per [...]

Surrogacy and IVF: How Different They Are

Surrogacy and IVF are two major assisted reproductive technologies that have revolutionized fertility treatment by offering alternative paths for potential parents to conceive children. Surrogacy involves a woman becoming pregnant with a child for another person or couple, known as the intended parents.

Pregnancies can be either traditional, where the surrogate uses her own eggs, or gestational, where the embryo is created through IVF using the genetic material of the intended parents.

IVF, known as In Vitro Fertilization, is a fertility treatment where eggs and sperm are combined in a lab to create embryos, which are then transferred to the uterus. While surrogacy directly addresses the inability to conceive, IVF helps couples with various infertility issues like blocked fallopian tubes or low sperm count.

Comparing Surrogacy and IVF

The primary differences between surrogacy and IVF are evident in their unique procedures, success rates, and implications. These include factors such as gestational surrogacy versus traditional surrogacy, as well as the embryo transfer process in IVF.

 

 

Costs and Success Rates

The costs and success rates of surrogacy and IVF vary greatly, depending on surrogacy agencies, medical procedures, and individual fertility conditions.

• The cost of surrogacy for individuals ranges broadly from $40,000 to $150,000, including surrogate compensation, agency fees, legal costs, and medical expenses.
• IVF cycle costs of $12,000 to $15,000 are common and do not include additional costs such as medication and embryo storage.

On average, success rates for surrogacy are between 50% and 75%, depending on the surrogate’s age and health, while success rates for IVF are approximately 40% for women under 35 and decline with age. In our clinic, we are proud to announce our success rate is above 85% based on over a decade of data and hundreds of procedures we conducted so far.

Factors that  affect the outcomes of surrogacy and IVF procedures are:

• embryo quality,
• underlying medical conditions,
• lifestyle choices
• quality of the process
• doctors’ expertise
• agency procedures.

 

Considerazioni legali

Legal considerations encompass surrogacy laws, legal agreements, and reproductive rights, all of which significantly impact the processes and outcomes of surrogacy and IVF procedures.

Surrogacy laws, varying across countries and states, determine the eligibility criteria for intended parents and surrogates and must be followed to ensure a legally protected process.

Legal agreements, drafted by lawyers representing both parties involved in a surrogacy arrangement, outline the rights and responsibilities of each party to prevent misunderstandings and conflicts and clarify issues such as parental rights and financial obligations.

Reproductive and parental rights, closely linked to legal considerations, determine access to assisted reproduction and the determination of legal parentage post-childbirth.

 

 

Benefits and Drawbacks of Surrogacy

The benefits and drawbacks of surrogacy encompass surrogate compensation packages, the surrogate journey, and potential risks and benefits to intended parents and surrogates.

Advantages for Intended Parents

The most significant benefit of surrogacy for intended parents is the ability to establish a genetic connection with their child, which plays a pivotal role in shaping their overall experience of parenthood and expanding their family. Surrogacy allows intended parents to overcome infertility challenges and offers a practical solution for couples unable to conceive.

For many intended parents, using a surrogate is the sole means to experience pregnancy and childbirth while maintaining a biological link with their child. This aspect boosts their sense of contentment and completeness within their family, helping them realize the family they have always dreamed of creating.

 

 

Challenges for Surrogates

Surrogates face various challenges, encompassing medical and psychological implications, along with the significant commitment and risks associated with the surrogacy journey.

The medical procedures involved in surrogacy, such as hormonal treatments and embryo transfer, impact the surrogate both physically and emotionally.

The psychological complexities of carrying a child for another individual or couple require proper emotional support and counseling throughout the process.

The decision to become a surrogate has far-reaching effects on the surrogate’s personal life, relationships, and future plans.

Adequate compensation and a supportive environment are fundamental for the well-being of surrogates and a successful surrogacy.

 

 

Benefits and Drawbacks of IVF

When considering in vitro fertilization (IVF), we recommend you consider the advantages and disadvantages. While IVF offers a higher success rate for pregnancy in infertile couples, it is important to acknowledge the potential drawbacks and risks associated with IVF, such as side effects and the intricacies of the IVF process.

Advantages for Couples with Fertility Issues

In vitro fertilization (IVF) offers several key benefits for treating infertility, including a high success rate and access to advanced technologies such as egg retrieval and embryo implantation. Advancements in assisted reproductive technology have greatly enhanced the chances of successful conception for couples struggling with infertility.

The IVF process entails hormone stimulation to generate multiple eggs, which are then retrieved through a minimally invasive procedure. Subsequently, the eggs are fertilized in a laboratory, and the resulting embryos are meticulously monitored before being transferred into the uterus for potential implantation. A personalized approach to fertility treatment positions IVF as a highly promising solution for various types of infertility.

 

 

Potential Risks and Complications

IVF does carry risks and complications, including side effects, medication reactions, and procedural risks while offering the potential for pregnancy. Side effects of IVF range from mild to severe and commonly include:

• bloating,
• abdominal pain,
• psychological impacts like mood swings due to hormonal changes
• problems from the fertility medications used in IVF treatment, such as headaches, hot flashes, and allergic reactions.

Procedural risks during the egg retrieval and embryo transfer steps in IVF include infections, bleeding, and the potential for damage to surrounding structures. We recommend regular monitoring and risk management throughout the entire IVF process to increase safety and chances for success.

 

 

Choosing the Right Option for You

The decision to use surrogacy or in vitro fertilization (IVF) as a reproductive option is influenced by the preparation required for each method and the potential psychological implications associated with them.

Conclusione

When deciding between surrogacy and IVF, the main factors to consider include medical requirements, the involvement of a fertility specialist, and the necessity for genetic counseling. The choice between surrogacy and IVF is a complex decision influenced by medical needs, the role of a fertility specialist, and the importance of genetic counseling.

Medical conditions may dictate whether IVF or surrogacy is the more suitable option, particularly when individuals have underlying health issues that favor one over the other. A fertility specialist plays a key role in evaluating the individual’s situation and guiding prospective parents through the assisted reproduction process. Genetic counseling helps individuals comprehend the consequences of their decisions and navigate any inherited factors that could impact their choices.

 

 

Domande frequenti

What is the difference between surrogacy and IVF?

Surrogacy is a process where a woman carries and gives birth to a child for another person or couple. At the same time, IVF (in vitro fertilization) is a fertility treatment where an egg and sperm are combined outside the body and then the resulting embryo is transferred into a woman’s uterus.

________________________

 

Which option, surrogacy or IVF, is more expensive?

Surrogacy is typically more expensive than IVF. The costs for surrogacy include compensation for the surrogate, medical expenses, legal fees, and agency fees. IVF costs vary depending on the clinic and specific treatments needed, but it is generally less expensive than surrogacy.

________________________

 

What are the legal considerations for surrogacy and IVF?

There are different legal considerations for each option. Surrogacy involves legal agreements between the surrogate and intended parents, as well as potential adoption proceedings. IVF involves legal agreements, but they are typically between the intended parents and the clinic. It is important to research and understand the legal aspects of both options before proceeding.

Which option, surrogacy or IVF, has a higher success rate?

The success rates for both surrogacy and IVF vary depending on individual factors such as age and health. However, IVF generally has a higher success rate as it involves directly implanting the embryo into the woman’s uterus. Surrogacy has a high success rate, but it may require multiple attempts before a successful pregnancy occurs.

________________________

 

Is surrogacy or IVF a better option for same-sex couples?

Both surrogacy and IVF are viable options for same-sex couples looking to have a biological child. Surrogacy may be a better option for male couples, as they would need to use a surrogate to carry the child. Female couples may choose either option, depending on their individual circumstances and preferences.

________________________

 

Are there any risks associated with surrogacy and IVF?

As with any medical procedure, there are some risks associated with both surrogacy and IVF: complications during pregnancy and childbirth, as well as potential emotional and psychological risks. It is important to thoroughly discuss and understand risks with medical professionals before making a decision.